Experts Disagree on Glazier Injury

, Written by Craig Smullin, Posted: Thu, February 9 2012 at 6:15 PM, Updated: Thu, February 9 2012 at 6:28 PM

After 7 days and nearly 50 witnesses the Jackson County District Attorney's office is wrapping up their presentation in the William Simmons murder trial.
   This as scientific anthropologists provide contradictory opinions on the stand.
    University of Oregon Forensic Anthropology Professor Dr. Jean McLaughlin looked at Kaelin Glazier's remains with this 2-million dollar electron microscope. she says sharp force trauma caused this injury to Kaelin Glazier's rib before she died.
    "You would have to come through here to injure it with a sharp object."
   That concurs with testimony Wednesday from Jackson County Medical Examiner Dr. James Olson.
     Neither doctor could say with absolute certainty how Glazier died or what caused the injury to her rib, though a knife could have done it... Dr. Veronica Vance agreed.
      "If it didn't hit any other bony structure it certainly is possible if it came through here I suppose. It depends on the size of the knife then too."
    Dr. Vance, a forensic scientist and anthropologist with the Oregon State Police did not however agree her fellow scientists on everything.
     She maintains her belief that the 10-millimeter injury on Glazier's 4th right rib happened after she died.
     "What I saw continued to be
     One thing they can all agree on - animals... likely rodents and a large dog or coyote damaged the remains.
    They also dismissed the possibility that the body was moved after decomposition began... calling it virtually impossible.
    "I'm not sure I could have set the body up that perfectly."
    Based on the the vegetation growth around the body and the deterioration of the clothing, the body had been in the field on Haven Road for at least 5 years... maybe even as far back as 1996 when the 15-year old disappeared.
   "Certainly I think that's a definite possibility, absolutely."
Also testifying late today, Dr. Steven Symes, an expert in sharp force trauma... he agreed with McLaughlin in saying the wound occurred around the time of Glazier's death.
    If that name sounds familiar it's because Dr.  Symes is working with Ashland PD in the David Grubbs case.

About the Author

Craig Smullin

NBC5 News Director Craig Smullin co-anchors NBC5 News at 6 and hosts the 5 on 5 Feature Interview on NBC5 News at 5.

A native of the San Francisco Bay Area, Craig graduated from Cal Poly in San Luis Obispo, California with a degree in Recreation Administration and Sports Management.

Since joining NBC5 News in 2005, Craig has performed virtually every job in the newsroom: News and Sports Reporter, Sports Anchor, Producer, series and segment Host and Anchor of NBC5 News at Sunrise and NBC5 News at 5. He became News Director in January, 2014.

When he's not managing a busy newsroom, Craig spends time with his wife, two young sons and two dogs. He is a dedicated fan of the San Francisco 49ers and Portland Trailblazers and loves snow boarding the slopes of Mt. Ashland.

Catch Craig anchoring weekdays on NBC5 News at 6pm.

Leave a Comment:

Note: Comments with profanity are automatically filtered and hidden. Verbal attacks towards others via our comments section will not be tolerated.